Wednesday, October 28, 2015
Fair and Transformative use
Fair use is used to justify an artist such as girl talk because it is considered a parody work of the original artists. Courts use fair use by seeing if the original is affected negatively by the new work. An example of what I am talking about can be boiled down to the bare financials of the two selected works. So If Girl Talk used too much of a sample of an original work than that work be copyright infringement. Since the original work isn’t effected and most people that would want to listen to Jay-Z wouldn’t opt to listen to Girl talk instead, they would continue to listen to the original Jay-Z song . As a former DJ, I am pretty familiar with how the music industry is regulated especially online. Everyone wants their music to be listening to but also paid for in addition. That’s why services like soundcloud and youtube are becoming much more regulated; artists want their money. Transformative use is another additional expansion to fair use. This is divided by commentary and criticism and or a parody which is what the show south park is famous for. South Park is considered a very successful parody; constantly sued by major companies and other public figures. They all lose in court due to the fact that the entire main cast are cartoon eight year olds. Most people tend to forget that that they have the legal right to use their name or brand but only because of it’s parody value.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I absolutely love South Park and Jay-Z.
ReplyDeleteI just posted to Courtney about the Grey Album - Mashup of The Beatles and Jay-Z by Danger Mouse. Check it out. He got in trouble with EMI for the same sort of copyright stuff but people kept re-releasing his album on YouTube and eventually YouTube just gave up/couldn't keep up with it. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeJQh6xjjTc&index=3&list=PLF27428868443F302
As for South Park, I just realized after our lecture that South Park gets away with using so many celebrity references and music in their episodes because of this and its really quite wonderful because they are in a way fighting for freedom of creativity. Example here of them using Party Rock Anthem. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCxIjmf68iU
Oh, and here is the wiki on The Grey Album it's really interesting and related to this class. "Although that work was copyrighted, it was released for the implicit purpose of encouraging mashups and remixes." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Grey_Album
Delete